The Scottish Information Commissioner - It's Public Knowledge
Tweet this page:
Text Size Icon

- Text Size Up | Down

Line Chart IconSelf-Assessment Module 5 - 

Conduct of Reviews

This module is designed to help your authority carry out an effective review of its response to a request. If an individual is unhappy either with the response they have received or the way in which their request was handled, they have a right to request a formal review by the authority. This module is not just about meeting this statutory requirement, however - good review practice brings wider benefits through improved public trust, increased service user satisfaction, and learning for future requests.

The module looks at the following areas of practice:

  • Leadership commitment - Are the benefits of proper FOI review processes, and the risks of failure to carry them out, acknowledged by leaders and managers in the authority?
  • Clear but flexible process - Is there a robust, proportionate procedure that is known and accessible by all relevant staff? Are reviews carried out independently of those answering requests?
  • Staff resources and training - Do those carrying out reviews receive appropriate training, understand their responsibilities and have sufficient authority to challenge original responses?
  • Responsive and evolving authority - Does the authority monitor the outcomes of reviews and SIC decisions and learn from them in improving FOI and wider customer service practice?

You will need

 Download Description of contents / purpose 
PDF iconHow to carry out an FOI self-assessment Our detailed guide to completing the five self-assessment stages of a module.

PDF icon

Module 5: Standards and Criteria

  • Introduction to this module
  • Expected outcomes and legal context
  • Characteristics of excellent practice
  • Ratings and evaluation criteria
Word DocumentModule 5: Assessment Questions and Evidence Grid  Workbook of module questions, with sections to record evidence, strengths and areas for improvement
 Summary of FindingsWord Document  A form to record the assessment findings and give your authority a performance rating for this module.
 Improvement Action PlanWord Document  A form to plan actions to improve performance

Back to self-assessment toolkit home page

Back to Top